|
Nietzsche, Friedrich: Austrian philosopher, 1844-1900. A linguist by profession, with a great gift for
language and a brilliant mind, he had throughout his life bad health,
and finally died completely insane, probably because of tertiary
syphilis, though this is not certain. He wrote more than ten
books and was a master of German prose. One can distinguish several
phases or approaches in his books, all of which are well-written but
some of which are obscure nevertheless. In any case, he was
aristocratic, pessimistic and mostly
materialistic, though his attitude to
science and rationality differed considerably in his different phases
and books.
He has been widely influential in artistic circles, if only because
he brilliantly expresses a young man's cynicism about the world in
combination with personal high aspirations, and also as one of the main
inspirators of Adolf Hitler and national socialism, though it is very
probable that Nietzsche would have despised Hitler, and it is certain
that Nietzsche was neither an antisemite nor a German nationalist nor a
socialist in any sense.
A sympathetic reading of him tends to see him as an aristocratic
individualist of great gifts, unfortunately side-tracked and finally
upset by serious bad health; a less sympathetic reading sees him as a
disturbed personality of great linguistic gifts who through his cravings
for personal superiority, aristocracy and a master-race laid, albeit
unwittingly, the foundations for fascism and national socialism.
What is certain in any case, however one tries to understand him, is
that almost all of his followers have not understood him, but only used
such of his brilliancies as fitted their own ends.
One of his phrases and ideals that appealed to Hitler and national
socialists was the notion of a Herrenmoral: A morality for
leaders of the master race, of whom Nietzsche liked to think that the
world exists mostly for their purposes, and that, being naturally
superior, they had, thereby and therefore, the right, and possibly the
duty, to subvert and use everybody else for their - superior,
enlightened - ends. (It should be clear that, however one thinks about
the distribution of talents, this Nietzschean opinion also seems a prime
example of Adlerian psychological compensation for weakness and
inferiority, and that it was this aspect that, unwittingly, grabbed
Hitler and other national socialists, who strongly craved superiority.)
The general problem with Nietzsche as a philosopher is that he was
very good at writing philosophical and psychological aphorisms, but no
good at all at writing systematic rational philosophical expositions of
his ideas.
Another problem is that his works have not been fully published (and
he became insane aged 44) and that his sister has falsified some of
these to satisfy her own antisemitism. His last unpublished work, "The
Will to Power", has been edited and published by Schlechta, but is
supposed to be incomplete.
If Seneca was right that there is no genius without a tincture of
madness, Nietzsche is a good example of a mad philosophical genius,
whose genius was mostly linguistic: A great gift for spectacular
phrasing, but a far lesser gift for systematic rational thinking and
exposition.
|