|
Conditionals: Kinds of if-then
connection. In logic there are quite a few kinds of
conditionals. I will later treat some of these, but start with two
remarks on standard conditionals.
The standard bivalent if-then is defined thus: (if p then q)
is true iff (p) is not true or (q) is true, and (if p then q) is not
true iff (p) is true and (q) is not true. This is adequate for most
mathematical argumentation, and also rather close to most usages of
if-then in natural language, but for some cases other kinds of if-then
are useful, while also the standard definition of if-then comes with
some difficulties. (See: Paradoxes of implication.)
The standard bivalent if-then corresponds to the if-then of
inference, indeed provably so by what is known as the Deduction
Theorem: From (if p then q) it follows that if (p) one can infer (q),
and conversely if one can prove that one can infer (q) if (p) is true,
then (if p then q) is true. The difference is that the if-then of
inference is, besides an if-then, a rewriting rule, that permits an
action, namely the inference of the
conclusion if the premisses of the
rule are all
true.
|